Event Summary Blog
By Sarah Shnouda, Adham Hamdy, and Dalia El Sabbagh
Introduction
The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region is witnessing a decline in food security due to the repercussions of the wars in Ukraine, the war in Sudan, the protracted crises in Yemen, and the state of global inflation of food prices, where Egypt is one of the countries most affected.[1] The World Bank estimates food insecurity for 2023 at 6.4%, representing 6.9 million malnourished people in Egypt.[2] Food security is also a greater challenge for mothers and children, as lack of proper nutrition in pregnancy or early childhood leads to an increased risk of stunting, wasting and loss of education outcomes
In extension of the successful collaborations between the Egyptian Food Bank's (EFB) Growth Lab, The International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), and Sawiris Foundation for Social Development (SFSD), the three collaborating parties launched “Bridging Evidence and Policy” Seminar Series. As the title hints, the seminar series aims to highlight evidence from ongoing and contextual development programs in Egypt and regionally, establishing various links to inform policy.
The launch event which took place on May 7th, 2023, titled “Impact Evaluation of Social Protection Programs” showcased evidence and insights newly generated. The event showcased key studies designed to evaluate key social protection programs through rigorous research and randomized control impact evaluations that are relevant to contemporary social protection challenges in Egypt.
Series Launch
Introducing the series, Mr. Abdelrahman Nagy, Director of Learning and Strategy at SFSD, gave an overview of the shift in development practices in Egypt, especially during project design phases from depending on existing knowledge and experience to designing an informative evidence-based approach, in light of limited resources. Dr. Mohamed El-Karamany, Director of Growth Lab at EFB, highlighted that the philosophy of evidence-based programing pioneered in Egypt by SFSD, EFB, and IFPRI is important to mainstream throughout the NGO community in the country, to effectively support the government in adopting policies that are tested and deemed effective based on scientific evidence. On his part, Dr. Kibrom Abay, Egypt Country Program Leader at IFPRI, followed by affirming the importance of informing our public policy against any crisis using evidence-based approaches.
Opening Remarks
Mr. Mohsen Sarhan, CEO of the EFB, communicated his pleasure to see social interventions in the Egyptian community move towards evidence-based programing as well as establishing impact evaluation studies in a way that will transform the sector of civil society. This will help target social protection services to the most deserving people in the community. He emphasized that partnerships between Community Based Organizations (CBOs) , project partners, and the Ministry of Social Solidarity (MoSS) are paramount to achieve this change.
Eng. Noura Selim, Executive Director of SFSD, highlighted that SFSD prioritizes continuous collaborative learning and moving towards funding its programs around scientific evidence. Eng. Selim highlighted that the importance of the event stems from its linkage between SFSD’s main objective of serving the most deserving and doing so with the most efficient use of resources, directed by evidence and not just good intentions.
Dr. Khaled El-Attar, Deputy Minister, Ministry of Communication and Information Technology (MCIT) highlighted the ministry’s strategy to build interlinked databases that help social protection system to function efficiently among other benefits. Dr. El-Attar emphasized that such databases would play a pivotal role in supporting evidence-based policies relevant to many stakeholders, through analysis of big data.
H.E Dr. Nevine El-Kabbaj, Minister of Social Solidarity in Egypt (MOSS), confirmed the importance of digitization, mentioning the growing momentum in the Egyptian government towards evidence-based policies and the indispensable link between policy and digitization. Speaking on nutrition, El-Kabbaj emphasized the complexity of this developmental issue, which has direct ramifications on childhood development, maternal and child health, environmental factors, agriculture, food security and poverty reduction.
Evidence for social protection in Egypt
During main presentations, Dr. Kibrom Abay presented the preliminary findings from the General Feeding Program (GFP) impact evaluation’s baseline and midline surveys that target female headed households. Abay highlighted the role of the GFP in protecting households’ nutrition needs from dramatically falling due to inflation and economic instability between the collection of the baseline (August 2022) and the midline (March 2023), as well as showing the difference in magnitude of nutritional support comparing the two different type of food boxes distributed by the GFP.
Dr. Sikandra Kurdi presented the results of the Takaful & Karama impact evaluation as well as the Forsa baseline. Results in the short-term show the need to continue and expand the program in the current economic circumstances given that Takaful transfers increased total consumption and food spending. Kurdi also demonstrated a set of characteristics of Forsa participants, the self-selection graduation project from takaful that is currently being piloted by the government in order to understand the different possibilities of supporting the people in need.
In that sense, Ragui Assad, Professor of Planning and Public Affairs at the University of Minnesota and Research Fellow at the Economic Research Forum (ERF), presented the lessons learnt from the impact evaluation of the ultra-poor graduation project “Bab Amal” targeting ultra-poor (TUP) program. The study measures the effect of multidimensional interventions including productive assets and cash transfers on poor households, while comparing the magnitude of the effect for different transfers quantities. Results show the outcomes improvement for the participants in different interventions compared to the control group including revenue from livestock, household income and female employment with its different magnitudes.
Click here to be redirected to speakers' presentations and slides
Conclusions
Food security has deep health and economic ramifications, which brings together partners and organizers of the Bridging Evidence & Policy series as a collaborative scientific beacon into harder times. The paramount importance of creating complementary social protection programs across government entities is becoming clearer, and if designed correctly, will have a positive impact on the lives of the poor and ultra-poor in Egypt. SFSD, EFB, and IFPRI commit to scientific investments and partnerships in the way forward to enable public policy to make the best wide scale interventions, away from poverty traps, and eventually towards the socioeconomic empowerment of the poorest and most vulnerable households in our community.
Photo Album
Interviews with (Dr. Mohamed Elkaramny & Eng. Noura Selim)
Interviews with (Mr. Abdelrahman Nagy & Dr. Abay Kibrom)
Click here to be redirected to event page
[1] Food Security Update | World Bank Response to Rising Food Insecurity: May 22, 2023 estimates (nominal YoY food prices inflation as 63%) https://t.co/6IwfYyb26V
[2]Gatti, Roberta, et al. "Altered Destinies: The Long-Term Effects of Rising Prices and Food Insecurity in the Middle East and North Africa." (2023). World Bank: Middle East and North Africa Economic Update
[3] Fact sheets - Malnutrition. (2021, June 9). Fact Sheets - Malnutrition. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/malnutrition
